RSS Feed

Rent-seeking & teacher unions

January 30, 2014 by Tunya

The term rent-seeking is defined as when teacher unions prefer different school inputs than parents primarily because their

objectives are not solely the maximization of student achievement.

Hoxby, C. M. 1996. “How Teacher Unions Affect Education Production.” Quarterly

Journal of Economics, v11: pp670-718. 

The results indicate that “mobile” parents may be able to pressure teachers into accepting lower budget increases, higher levels of effort, and add fewer administrative encumbrances. Hoxby concludes that unions are primarily rent seeking

and may be a primary means in which the lack of district competition leads to an increase in inputs and worse student performance. Instead, these results arguably suggest that teachers unions effectively separate their rent-seeking quality from their role as educators.    

Those opposed to teachers unions argue that they have separate agendas from

improving education quality. Hoxby (1996) argues that, aside from their goal of

improving education quality, teachers unions have a rent-seeking attribute—they prefer

different school inputs than parents primarily because their objectives are not solely the Castelo 5

maximization of student achievement. This rent-seeking quality could prevent optimal

inputs from entering the educational system. For example, teachers unions tend to dislike

the use of merit pay and tend to oppose anything that induces competition among schools

or teachers

http://publicpolicy.stanford.edu/group/siepr/cgi-bin/pubpol/?q=system/files/shared/documents/Castelo.pdf


No Comments

No comments yet.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.